Only the recent third quest for the historical jesus, which began in the later. The jesus of history controversy, in ernst kasemann, new testament questions of today phila delphia. On the scholarly side, kasemann was known as one of the founders of the second quest for the historical jesus, as a leading theologian of paul and pauline apocalyptic, and as a student of johns gospel. Schweitzers book does not pretend to be an impartial survey.
If that is the effect of the pauline doctrine ofjustification and it. The problem of the historical jesus, in ernst kisemann, essays on new testament themes sbt 41. Kasemann maintains that paul stresses both the persons individuality and his or her place within the cosmos. It seeks to provide information about who jesus was. In this book sanders shows how the gospels portrait of jesus fits very. Kasemann is often credited with resuscitating the quest with a paper entitled the problem of the historical jesus 1953, but the new quest actually got its name from the book a new quest for the historical jesus published in 1959 by j. The inner core of all his written work, as the following letters attest, was his highly individual reception of justification by faith. Looking back from the vantagepoint of 1973, he could write that this early experience determined his course of study and in some sense, as befits a theologian, my life. On 23 october 1953, ernst kasemann gave a nowfamous lecture to a group of former bultmann students on the problem of the historical jesus, thereby beginning a significantly new phase, which quickly styled itself the new quest for the historical jesus. This book has the potential to guide jesus studies beyond the third quest and demand to be consulted by any scholar who discards, adopts, or adapts historical. Before the nineteenth century, when christians sought to understand jesus and the ancient world depicted in the gospels, they adhered to naturalistic literalism.
The problem is that the entire historical jesus movement is a product of the 20th century philosophy of naturalism, in that all debate begins with a shared, yet concealed, presupposition that anything outside the realm of natural explanation can never be backed by historical evidence. The question about the historical jesus is legitimately the question about the continuity of the gospel in the discontinuity of the times and in the variation of the kerygma. Ernst kasemanns quest for the historical jesus revisited free download. But in recent years, the trailblazing work of ernst kasemann has seen a new quest for the historical jesus. Scholars of the new quest generally focused on jesus as a teacher of. One of the first to undertake such an investigation was the orientalist hermann samuel reimarus 16941768, with whose work albert schweitzer begins his classic work, the quest of. This historicallysignificant essayas well as the rest of the book, of coursewill be of great interest to anyone studying the historical jesus, as well as the early christian community. The first largely protestant quest from the late eighteenth to the late nineteenth century breathed the air of the enlightenment, presenting jesus in utterly rational terms, explaining his. Kasemanns october 20, 1953 lecture titled the problem of the historical. His study of the historical jesus paints a picture not unfamiliar to christians jesus was indeed the real historical figure that the new testament says he was. Against every idealistic conception of history as a dialectical synthesis of immanent processes, apocalyptic theology sets the god revealed in the crucifixion of jesus christ, that is, the god who identifies unreservedly with all those who are laid to waste by the march of history. It is obvious that certain narratives in the new testament contradict each other and cannot be woven into a historically coherent whole. Ernst kasemanns quest for the historical jesus revisited scribd. Beginning in the 1950s there was a renewed interest in the scholarly world in the historical jesus.
Kasemann treats major themes in pauls thought with his customary originality, clarity, and brilliance. Upon the recommendation of brandon wason i decided to read ernst kasemanns article the problem of the historical jesus. For this reason the historical element in the story of jesus has, in these other writings, shrunk almost to the vanishing. Quizlet flashcards, activities and games help you improve your grades. Reimarus work was made popular by albert schweitzer, whose book the quest for the historical jesus 1906 stands as one of the most influential books on jesus in critical scholarship. This work was an extension of the work in the bultmann school cf. The christology of jesus by ben witherington iii, 1990. Thoughts on kasemann and the historical jesus paul of tarsus. Kasemann was involved with what is known as the new quest for the historical jesus, a new phase of scholarly interest in working out what could possibly be ascertained historically about jesus. Kasemann argues that the gospels were formed in three phases for the purpose preaching about jesus, and were not intended to withstand interrogation of modern historical criticism. For the book by albert schweitzer, see the quest of the historical jesus. The quest for the historical jesus consists of academic efforts to determine what words and. An analy sis of kasemanns positions on the uniqueness of the gospel genre and.
Naturalistic literalism is the practice of reading the scriptures and accepting the events that are described therein as the literal truth. Project muse the theological relevance of the historical. Jesus, skepticism, and the problem of history brings together a stellar lineup of new testament scholars who contend that historical jesus scholarship is far from dead. Kasemanns work on the historical jesus, the present study concludes that, while several of adams points against historical criticism writ large may well be correct, his direct attack on kasemann is misplaced. Albert schweitzer and rudolf bultmann immobilised work on the historical jesus for decades. Now the claim is often made in books on the historical jesus that, in principle, this. It is apocalypticism, antisemitism and the historical jesus john s.
Ernst kasemann, an active member of the confessing church this is a book which grew out of the whitehot anger of a man who saw freedom of thought within the church, reason and common sense, and above all the effectiveness of the church in its influence on society endangered by the reactionary pressures of a movement which thrived on superficial slogans and emotionalism. Essays on new testament themes study in bible theology. These scholars all find value in using the tools of contemporary historical methods in the study of jesus and christian origins. Jesus many faces the historical jesus from jesus to. A tribute to ernst kasemann and a theological testament. Quest for the historical jesus part ii centre for public christianity. Will the dutch and south africans take seriously nt. The first quest was the nineteenth century german endeavour so memorably reported by albert schweitzers the quest of the historical jesus.
The second quest began with the 1953 marburg lecture by ernst kasemann, the problem of the historical jesus. In terms of searching for the historical jesus, history has indeed repeated itself through the first and second quest and is threatening to do so again in the contemporary third quest. Kasemann, the problem of the historical jesus 1954, essays on new testament themes london 1964 37 gt. These attempts at constructing a biography of jesus came to be known as the first quest for the historical jesus, a term effectively coined by albert schweitzers book which was originally titled the quest of the historical jesus. Following kasemann these scholars devised rigorous tests for working out. Was the centre of his thought justification or salvation history kasemann vs stendahl.
Perrin rediscovering the teachings of jesus london 1967 39 and j. A critical study of its progress from reimarus to wrede. Today, the quest for the jesus of history is alive and well. Quests of the historical jesus historical investigation of the jesus tradition untrammelled by theological agendas is the product of the 18thcentury enlightenment.
How, then, do scholars construct who the historical jesus. Deegan i contemporary concern with the problems, exegetical and vtheological, relating to the nature and significance of the historical jesus, is receiving widespread attention. Issues include the nature of the historical jesus, the nature of the early christian documents, and the origins of the christian faith in a risen jesus christ. But in the 1950s, ernst kasemann, a former student of bultmanns, reopened. The question of historical jesus in ernst kasemann revisited from the third quest article in etudes theologiques et religieuses 794. The question of historical jesus in ernst kasemann. Jesus could share neither christian nor jewish beliefs, silly. The purpose of this web page is to explain and explore some of the theories offered up by contemporary scholars on the historical jesus and the origins of the christian religion. They conclude, the quest for the historical jesus was regarded as a failed undertaking by liberal theology. Encountering the new testament ch 11 and 12 study guide by aacoffman includes 22 questions covering vocabulary, terms and more. He has his own solution of the problems, and it is not to be expected that english students will endorse the whole of his view of the gospel history, any more than his german fellowworkers have done. Ernst kasemann on why the gospels are ahistorical and.
Theres a connection between the two, certainly, but history cannot measure what we learn through faith, he says. In fact, the current wave of books constitutes a third quest for the historical jesus. The book s larger ramifications as a thorough end to the third quest will provide a pressure valve for thousands of scholars who view historical jesus studies as outmoded and misguided. Ernst kasemann, the problem of the historical jesus e. Ernst kasemann 12 july 1906 17 february 1998 was a german lutheran theologian and professor of new testament in mainz 19461951, gottingen 19511959 and tubingen 19591971. This book makes an interim stocktaking in a new orientation of theology which has come about in the second half of the twentieth century. Seeking to overcome the pessimism cast by schweitzer and repeated by bultmann regarding what can be known historically about jesus, the second quest also produced lives of jesus, often tinged with notions of the existential relevance of the jesus who emerges from these.
The quest of the historical jesus project gutenberg. Kasemann and others launched the new quest for the historical jesus, and because some modern scholars continue to be skeptical about the possibility of saying anything significant about the historical jesus selfunderstanding, it may rightly be asked. The modern problem of the historical jesus was already raised, to some degree, by the thirdcentury christian theologian and philosopher origen. Paul althaus in his book the socalled kerygma and the historical jesus puts the matter thus. The modern problem of the historical jesus was already raised, to some degree. This outstanding book provides an indepth historical study of the place of jesus in the religious life, beliefs, and worship of christians from the beginnings of the christian movement down to the late second century. Below it is argued that based on the lessons of the first two quests, evangelicals should. Many of these were apocalyptic works, like the canonical books of daniel and. On new years day 20 i was on the train from frankfurt back to hamburg when i read a book that unveiled the whole problem with a high degree of honesty. He described the gospels as histories but also stated that they narrate certain events that could not have happened. Yet the new testament is not a modern history book.
Encountering the new testament ch 11 and 12 flashcards. A natural sequel to the historical jesus quest, the historic. With this formula, so kasemann says, faith in the resurrection of jesus does not. Robinson published a book, a new quest of the historical jesus. New contributions to the christproblem published in english 1907 as the. The new quest was intiated by ernst kasemann s lecture, the problem of the historical jesus, essays on new testament themes, tr. Kasemann effectively started this phase when he published his famous article the problem of the historical jesus during 1954, originally his inaugural lecture as professor in gottingen in 1951. Commentary on romans by ernst kasemann, paperback barnes.
196 379 880 1076 981 66 476 1477 666 571 840 1485 788 692 197 1279 401 786 1389 1082 1245 432 1175 1346 1370 550 340 230 308 837 1443 364 1489 1214 309 1482